The Fear of 13

A SAMUEL FRENCH, INC. TITLE

The Fear of 13

Full-Length Play, Drama  /  1w, 8m

By Lindsey Ferrentino
Based on the film directed by David Sington

Based on the extraordinary true story of Nick Yarris and the subsequent documentary film by David Sington, this compelling Broadway drama documents the experience of a naive young man who is wrongly convicted of murder. 

Image: 2026 Broadway Production (Emilio Madrid)

  • Cast Size
    Cast Size
    1w, 8m
  • Duration
    Duration
    120 minutes (2 hours)
  • SubGenre
    Subgenre
    Adaptation (Stage & Screen), Docudrama/History
  • Audience
    Target Audience
    Adult
Accolades
Accolades
  • Nominee: Two 2025 Olivier Awards, including Best New Play

Details

Summary

“The first thing you should know is that this is true. It’s what actually happened. I know it seems like it’s a story – inside of a story – inside of a story. But that’s how it is for most people. At least the ones in here.”

Nick’s got a story to tell you. About how a routine traffic stop turned into a conviction for murder. About how he spent the next 22 years on Death Row. About how he finally petitioned the court to ask not for an appeal, but for his execution date. And about what happened next. Based on the extraordinary true story of Nick Yarris and the subsequent documentary film by David Sington, Lindsey Ferrentino’s gripping new play is a searing exploration of perseverance, justice and renewal.

History

After premiering at the Donmar Warehouse on October 4, 2024, The Fear of 13 opened on Broadway at the James Earl Jones Theatre on March 9, 2026. Directed by David Cromer, the Broadway production starred Adrian Brody and Tessa Thompson.

NICK YARRIS [MAN 1]
JACKIE SCHAFFER
GUARD
VARIOUS INCARCERATED MEN ON DEATH ROW who sing and play both the incarcerated and the innocent, who double as the following characters:

MAN 2 – Lieutenant Walker, Sheriff 1, Nick’s Father, Police Officer 2, Captain, Bailiff, Arthur Craig, Jury Foreman
MAN 3 – Joe Bullen, Waiter, Pawn Shop Owner, Officer Benjamin Wright
MAN 4 – Wesley, Sheriff 2, Cloakroom Attendant, Eddie, Public Defender
MAN 5 – Butch, Anthony Manilla, Prosecutor, Clerk, Older Man
MAN 6 – Some Guard, Nick’s Mother, Police Officer 1, Cop, Judge Kelly, Judge Giles

  • Time Period New Millennium/21st Century, 1990s, 1980s
  • Setting

    A liminal space suggesting multiple locations in Nick’s life. 1981 to early 2000s.

  • Features Contemporary Costumes/Street Clothes
  • Duration 120 minutes (2 hours)
  • Cautions
    • Gun Shots
    • Strong Language
    • Mild Adult Themes

Media

★★★★★ “Thrilling… one of the best new plays of the year.” – WhatsOnStage

“[A] gut-wrenching tale of death row injustice… unmissable.” – The Telegraph

★★★★★ “A memorable evening of theatre… Ferrentino gives us a tight and robust script which, rather than focusing on the iniquities of crime and punishment, instead showcases the reality of those who have endured something unwarranted.” – Theatre Weekly

“A deeply moving play about Yarris’ experience on death row, the woman who became his lifeline and his eventual exoneration after more than two decades behind bars.” – Variety

“Absorbing… [a] bizarre, dramatic and heartbreaking true story.” – The Wrap

★★★★★ “Thrilling… one of the best new plays of the year… Ferrentino’s script gallops with innovative charm where it could, quite easily, have trotted along with pedestrian paint-by-numbers storytelling. The result is a harder road to travel but one that reaps much greater rewards.” – WhatsOnStage

“Gripping… Lindsey Ferrentino’s clear storytelling slips down effortlessly as she exposes the true story of Nick Yarris, trapped on death row in Pennsylvania for 22 years for a murder he didn’t commit… It’s engrossing and poignant.” – The Independent

“Slickly theatrical… a cracking piece of storytelling.” – TimeOut London

Videos

  • The Fear of 13 – Broadway Trailer youtube thumbnail

    The Fear of 13 – Broadway Trailer

  • The Fear of 13 – Behind the Scenes at Donmar Warehouse youtube thumbnail

    The Fear of 13 – Behind the Scenes at Donmar Warehouse

  • The Fear of 13 – Broadway Cast and Crew Discuss the Play youtube thumbnail

    The Fear of 13 – Broadway Cast and Crew Discuss the Play

  • Adrian Brody and Tessa Thompson on The Fear of 13 youtube thumbnail

    Adrian Brody and Tessa Thompson on The Fear of 13

Photos

  • The Fear of 13

    Image: 2026 Broadway Production (Emilio Madrid)

  • The Fear of 13

    Image: 2026 Broadway Production (Emilio Madrid)

Authors

Lindsey Ferrentino

Lindsey Ferrentino is a playwright who was named Variety’s 2025 “Broadway Stars to Watch” as she premiered two shows on Broadway last season with The Fear of 13 and The Queen of Versailles. Her work includes the Olivier Award-nominated play The Fear of 13 (Donmar Warehouse, L ...

View full profile

Now Playing

Related