1. “Welcome, Sir, I'm So Delighted” – Debienne, Rémy, Faust, Mephistopheles, Richard, Raoul & Jammes
(“Jamais, foi de Cicerone” from La Vie Parisienne by Jacques Offenbach)
2. “Accursed All Base Pursuit of Earthly Pleasure” – Faust
(“Maudites soyez-vois” from Faust by Charles Gounod)
3. “How Dare She!” – Raoul
(“O inferno! Amelia qui!” from Simon Boccanegra by Giuseppe Verdi)
4. “Late Last Night I'm in the Cellars” – The Groom
(“Son lo spirito che nega” from Mefistofele by Arrigo Boito)
5. “All of My Dreams Faded Suddenly” – Christine
(“Mĕsic̆ku na nebi hlubokem” from Rusalka by Antonín Dvořák)
6. “While Floating High Above” – Phantom
(“Je crois entendre encore” from Les Pêcheurs de Perles by Georges Bizet)
7. “She Says She's Got the Nodules” – Faust, Carlotta, Richard, Rémy, Jammes, Debienne, Stage Hands, Christine & Lisette
(“A Paris nous arrivons en masse” from La Vie Parisienne by Jacques Offenbach)
8. “What Do I See?” – Christine (Carlotta)
(“Que vois-je là?” from Faust by Charles Gounod)
9. “To Pain My Heart Selfishly Dooms Me” – Phantom, Raoul & Christine
(“Adieu! Je ne veux pas te suivre, Fantôme” from Les Contes d'Hoffmann by Jacques Offenbach)
10. “Ah! Do I Hear My Lover's Voice?” – Faust & Christine
(“Ah! C'est la voix!” from Faust by Charles Gounod)
11. “No Sign! I See No Sign!” – Debienne, Richard, Raoul, Rémy, Dominique, Faust, Lisette, Stage Hands, Jammes & Madam Giry
(“Du weißt daß, meine Frist” from Der Freischütz by Carl Maria von Weber, and “Rè dall 'abisso, affrettati” from Un Ballo in Maschera by Giuseppe Verdi)
12. “Somewhere Above the Sun Shines Bright” – Christine
(“Non so le tetre immagini” from Il Corsaro by Giuseppe Verdi)
13. “Born with a Monstrous Countenance” – Persian
(“Mentre gonfiarsi l'anima” from Attila by Giuseppe Verdi)
14. “In the Shadows, Dim and Dreary” – Raoul & Persian
(“Deserto sulla terra” from Il Trovatore by Giuseppe Verdi)
15. “What an Awful Way to Perish” – Faust, Persian, Madam Giry, Richard, Jammes & Raoul
(“Chi mi frena in tal momento” from Lucia di Lammermoor by Gaetano Donizetti)
16. “Ne'er Forsake Me, Here Remain” – Phantom
17. “Ne'er Forsake Me, Here Remain” (Reprise) – Phantom & Christine
(“Avant de quitter ces lieux” from Faustby Charles Gounod)
18. “He Will Not Go Without a Friend” – Company
(“Alla vita è sempre ugual“ from Don Giuvanni by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart)